Homemade Dog Treats: 7 Benefits (and What to Avoid)

If you’re comparing homemade dog treats vs. store-bought, the biggest difference is control: ingredients, freshness, and what’s left out. Here’s a practical guide to the benefits of homemade treats and the common ingredients we recommend avoiding.

7 benefits of homemade dog treats

• Fewer fillers and artificial additives

• Simple, limited-ingredient recipes

• Better for sensitive stomachs (when ingredients are chosen carefully)

• You can avoid common allergens

• Freshness you can see and smell

• Portion control for training

• You know exactly what your dog is eating

Ingredients we recommend avoiding

Every dog is different, but these are common ‘red flag’ ingredients many pet parents try to limit: artificial colors, artificial flavors, excessive sugar, and vague ‘meat by-products.’

How to choose a treat your dog will love

Start with one protein and one ‘fun’ flavor (like pumpkin or peanut butter), then watch how your dog responds. Keep treats small for training and save bigger pieces for special rewards.

Try small-batch treats from Bark N Krumble

We make small-batch, limited-ingredient dog treats...hand-cut and dehydrated for lasting freshness. If you’re looking for wholesome treats without the junk, browse our shop and find your dog’s new favorite.